Soloist: Ofer Falk
Five (4 + 1) equal strokes of the timpani open Beethoven’s violin concerto.
Out of this simple motif a whole movement of astonishing beauty emerges, slowly revealing itself in all its grandeur as it moves through its sonata form structure.
That (sonata form) is probably the only nod to convention in the whole first movement. With Beethoven, one can always be sure that he will push the boundaries of what was currently expected and acceptable in terms of structure, harmony and thematic development. The first two movements of this concerto are no different. Only the third movement somewhat fulfils expectations in that it is a Rondo with clearly delineated returns of the main theme. A rondo is a form in which the main idea (A) is repeated numerous times, but between each repetition a new idea is inserted. (B, C, D, E, etc.)
But - back to the beginning and the first movement.
That timpani motif of crotchets appears throughout the movement. For example, in the strings very near the beginning:
Or in the horns, trumpets and timpani accompanying the second theme:
Or in the bassoons in the development section:
These are only a very few examples. If you look through the score, you will be astonished at how embedded this motif is everywhere. It is like a bit of DNA that goes around the movement replicating itself, each time a little differently as it adapts to its musical environment.
This idea of using a motif to provide the glue that binds and unifies the music into a coherent structure is one of Beethoven’s signature contributions, and appears in many of his works. (e.g. 5th symphony). After Schumann and Brahms (who both made extensive use of the technique), the idea culminates in the Leitmotifs in Wagner’s later operas and the single movement tone poems of Richard Strauss.
The movement itself follows the convention of opening orchestral tutti which presents the main themes, followed by the entry of the soloist who interacts with these opening themes in different ways.
However, the role that Beethoven chooses for the soloist is improvisatory at its core. Rather than simply repeat the themes from the opening tutti, the violin here soars up, leaps about and provides a florid embellishment while the orchestra presents the themes below, but in a reduced version, so as not to overwhelm the violin.
There is an extensive development section, including a very beautiful middle section in G minor involving horns, bassoons and a hushed string section as well as the solo violin.
Following the recapitulation and soloist’s cadenza, there is a typically Beethoven coda – i.e. rather than a perfunctory cadential ending to the piece, it is more extended and references material from the movement’s exposition. Here, the coda starts off with a very quiet and heartfelt rendition of the main theme – this pp dynamic is held until the last few bars when the tension finally explodes into the final closing chords.
This movement excels at creating moments of magic – hushed orchestral accompaniments, loud and vibrant tuttis, wonderful and multicoloured orchestration. Amazingly beautiful and exciting.
The second movement continues with the improvisatory theme, but it is a more intimate setting – no flute, oboes, trumpets or timpani. It invites members of the orchestra to join in the improvisatory-like dialogue – most prominent are the clarinet and bassoon who both have extensive solos which respond and intertwine with the solo violin. Horns make a few important interventions and the strings contribute hushed (muted) pad textures to evoke an atmosphere of deep reverence.
Beethoven quite often uses the middle, slow movement in a concerto (also in chamber music) as a quasi interlude which joins the first and third movement together. That is the case here, despite the length of the movement – the little cadenza at the end which leads straight into the 3rd movement gives extra weight to this idea.
The third movement is, as mentioned above, a Rondo. A happy, lively and exhilarating end to a real masterpiece.
Overall and perhaps most importantly – pay attention throughout to the dialogue between the solo violin and the orchestra. That dialogue and how it manifests itself is at the core of the concerto form and Beethoven absolutely excels at revealing every possible detail of the relationship between the two.
Richard Gonski
May 2024